DE|EN
Background By Dr. Maximilian Mandl 20 min read

The GeoSphere dispersion model: what it shows and what it doesn't

The GeoSphere Austria dispersion calculation for the four closed quarries: where the 3-percent input value comes from, what the expert reports behind it show and how the model scales.

GeoSphere Austria, commissioned by the Office of the Burgenland Provincial Government, produced a dispersion calculation for asbestos fibres from the four closed quarries Pilgersdorf, Bernstein, Rumpersdorf and Badersdorf (GRAMM/GRAL model, file number 2026/UM/000160). We hold three versions: the overall version for all four quarries (version 1.1 of 29 April 2026, 131 pages), single-quarry versions for Bernstein and Rumpersdorf of the same day, and a recalculation for Pilgersdorf as of 2 June 2026. We hold a recalculation only for Pilgersdorf. The input values of all versions for the asbestos content come from four expert reports ("Befund und Gutachten") that the expert Michael Kochberger and ESW Consulting WRUSS prepared for the district authorities of Oberwart and Oberpullendorf. The authorities have not published these documents so far. We hold them. For copyright reasons we do not pass them on, but we quote from them and make the quoted passages available on request.

This post is the technical long form of the short analysis on the Burgenland page. It draws on the overall version (GeoSphere 2026a), the recalculation for Pilgersdorf of 2 June 2026 (GeoSphere 2026b), the single-quarry versions for Bernstein and Rumpersdorf (GeoSphere 2026c and 2026d) and on the four expert reports from which the input values come (Kochberger and WRUSS 2026a to 2026d, cited below by quarry).

What the model calculates

The model system GRAMM/GRAL couples a mesoscale wind-field model (GRAMM) with a validated Lagrangian particle model for the dispersion (GRAL; Öttl 2015a, 2015b; GRAL 2026). On the basis of a representative meteorological year (2023) and 1,080 base wind fields, it calculates the PM10 concentration at defined receptor points and, in a second step, converts these into WHO fibre concentrations. It considers the operational emissions from extraction, processing, truck movements and wind erosion from open areas and spoil heaps. Blasting is not included because of its short duration (GeoSphere 2026a, p. 13). For each quarry, the year with the highest extraction volume among the operating years 2022 to 2025 was used (p. 11).

The table below shows the results at receptor points with residential use and at further points. Annual mean and 95th percentile of the hourly values are given in WHO fibres/m³. For Pilgersdorf the June recalculation applies, for the other three quarries the April version.

Quarry Version Residential, highest annual mean Residential, highest 95th percentile Further receptor points
Pilgersdorf Recalculation 2 June 2026 54 (KO-01, Kogl) 381 (KO-01) Kindergarten 14 / 31; fish pond PD-01 135 / 837
Bernstein V1.1, 29 April 2026 37 (BE-03) 284 (BE-03) Commercial BE-02 38 / 365
Rumpersdorf V1.1, 29 April 2026 160 (RD-06) 771 (RD-06) Kindergarten 75 / 412; hunting lodge RD-01 730 / 4,353; fish ponds RD-02 208 / 1,565 and RD-03 347 / 2,459; abandoned house RD-04 164 / 896
Badersdorf V1.1, 29 April 2026 548 (BD-02) 2,813 (BD-02) Smallest distance between quarry and residential area

Values: annual mean / 95th percentile in WHO fibres/m³. The Pilgersdorf recalculation considers only the emissions on the quarry site. Its highest values are nevertheless higher than in the April version. In the April version, GeoSphere listed KO-01 as agricultural (37 / 206). At residential points, the highest values in that version were 29 (annual mean) and 168 (95th percentile), and 12 and 29 at the kindergarten. GeoSphere estimated the use of the receptor points from map and aerial photographs (GeoSphere 2026a, p. 53). Sources: GeoSphere 2026a, Tables 5-1 to 5-4 (pp. 64, 67, 70, 73); GeoSphere 2026b, Table 5-1 (p. 37).

Without quarry operation (only wind erosion of open areas), the annual means drop to a fraction: at most 26 WHO fibres/m³ in Badersdorf, at most 23 WHO fibres/m³ at the Rumpersdorf hunting lodge.

This is a first estimate with a recognised model. It answers the question "how high is the direct fibre concentration from ongoing quarry operation?" Four points of context are needed to read the values correctly.

1. The 3-percent input value: origin and robustness

The conversion from PM10 to asbestos mass runs through a single factor: a maximum asbestos mass content of 3% in the inhalable dust (grain sizes below 0.1 mm). The overall version states on page 80 (here and below, quotations from German originals are our translation): 3% was used for all four quarries ("maximum result from the Rumpersdorf quarry") "to convert the simulated PM10 results to asbestos". For the measured values it refers to the expert reports on the quarries (Kochberger 2026). The versions of these reports that we hold are dated 8 June 2026, that is, later than the dispersion calculation; the values that GeoSphere takes into its Table 2-5 agree with them.

Origin of the dust. Procedure 2 of TRGS 517 provides for dust measurements during processing, in the dust cloud as close to the source as possible (TRGS 517, Annex 2). But the quarries were closed. The product samples were therefore crushed in the laboratory, and the fraction below 0.1 mm was sieved off: the inhalable dust was estimated "by crushing the samples to be examined in the laboratory and sieving off the fraction < 0.1 mm" (Rumpersdorf, p. 14). The report itself calls the determination under procedure 2 "only indicative" (p. 20). In this sieve fraction, the mass share of WHO fibres was determined by the method BIA/IFA 7487. WHO fibres are fibres with a diameter below 3 µm, a length above 5 µm and a length-to-diameter ratio above 3:1. The total asbestos content, which covers all asbestos fibres regardless of this geometry, is several times higher in the same fraction.

Reference quantity. Table 8 of the Rumpersdorf report gives three numbers for each of the twelve product samples: the mass share of the fraction below 0.1 mm in the crushed sample, the WHO-fibre content in that fraction ("BIA-Asbestgehalt < 0,1 WHO") and the product of the two, the calculated mass content under procedure 2. For sample EBK 0/2, from which the 3% comes:

Sample EBK 0/2, Rumpersdorf Value
Mass share of the fraction below 0.1 mm in the crushed sample 7.79%
WHO-fibre content in that fraction 3.00%
Calculated for the total material 0.234%

GeoSphere uses the middle number, that is, the content in the dust itself and not a value converted to the total material. For converting PM10 this is the appropriate quantity, because PM10 is dust. The conversion to the total material serves a different purpose: it gives the mass content of the material. TRGS 517 itself divides the dust-related result by 100 for this (Annex 2, procedure 2), which would give 0.03% here; the Rumpersdorf report calculates with the fine share weighed in the laboratory and so arrives at 0.234%.

Maximum and mean. The 3% is the highest of twelve single values from Rumpersdorf and is applied to all four quarries. The reports also give the mean for each quarry, and they examined two further kinds of dust: for each quarry one dust that had settled on plant or machinery (procedure 1), and the dust that was raised when two products were dropped in a dustiness apparatus under DIN EN 15051 (procedure 3). The filters of these dustiness tests were analysed by CRB Analyse Service GmbH (p. 17 in each case), to which we also forward fibre samples.

Quarry Laboratory fraction below 0.1 mm: mean (samples) Laboratory fraction: maximum Settled dust (one sample) Raised dust (six runs)
Rumpersdorf 1.71% (12) 3.00% 3.4% 0.77 to 2.14%
Badersdorf 0.86% (14) 2.10% 2.8% 0.23 to 0.38%
Pilgersdorf 1.03% (11) 2.12% 1.27% 0.20 to 0.46%
Bernstein 1.16% (10) 1.90% 0.6% 0.34 to 1.87%

WHO fibres in mass percent of the respective dust. Sources: Kochberger and WRUSS 2026a to 2026d, in each case Table 6 (p. 15), Table 4 (p. 13) and Figures 2 and 3 (pp. 18 and 19).

For an annual mean, what counts is the mean content of the emitted dust. Measured against the mean of the laboratory fraction, the calculation value of 3% is 1.8 times (Rumpersdorf) to 3.5 times (Badersdorf) as high. Of the four settled dusts, one lies above 3%, the one from Rumpersdorf. In the raised dust the content was below it in all 24 runs.

Number of counted fibres. As far as the reports show, the single values rest on few counted fibres. In the fraction below 0.1 mm, the evaluation of the fibre geometry draws on 24 (Bernstein, ten samples) to 73 (Rumpersdorf, twelve samples) WHO fibres per quarry from all samples together (in each case Table 7, p. 16), that is, on two to six per sample on average. According to the Rumpersdorf report, the analytical method is intended only for contents below one mass percent; the dilutions required entail "a larger confidence interval of the measured values" (p. 20), and the interpretation has to be, "so to speak, by order of magnitude" (p. 31). A single maximum therefore carries neither as a ceiling nor as a ranking of the quarries. In purely statistical terms, too, the maximum of twelve samples is not the upper end of the distribution: for n samples, the share of the distribution below the maximum has the expected value n/(n+1), for twelve samples about 92%.

Transfer to PM10. The 3% applies to the fraction below 0.1 mm, that is, below 100 µm; the model applies it to particles below 10 µm. GeoSphere says so itself in its recalculation for Pilgersdorf: "With a diameter of <= 10 µm, PM10 is only a subset of the E dust. Until measurements of the asbestos mass content in PM10 are available, the measurement results for the E dust are applied to PM10." (GeoSphere 2026b, p. 22; E dust: inhalable dust, German E-Staub). The geometry speaks for an enrichment in PM10: WHO fibres are by definition thinner than 3 µm, while coarse grains contribute mass but no WHO fibres. Against it stands the only data set on the WHO-fibre content of raised dust: in the dustiness tests, the mass share of WHO fibres in the raised dust of six of eight products was, on average over the three runs, below that of the laboratory fraction of the product of the same name. The content in PM10 has not been measured.

Repeated stress. A second point is open upwards, and the reports name it themselves. Procedures 2 and 3 look at a single dust formation (Rumpersdorf, pp. 24 and 26). According to the report, dust formation occurs repeatedly in use and can add up "to the total potential of WHO fibres" (p. 8). The total asbestos content of the Rumpersdorf laboratory fraction is 16.54% on average.

For experts, or those who want to become one: the approach in fibres per milligram of dust

The dispersion calculation reports asbestos as fibre counts, not as mass. To do so it divides the asbestos mass by the mean weight of a WHO fibre from the laboratory fraction of the respective quarry (GeoSphere 2026a, pp. 24 and 25). Together with the 3%, this gives a fixed number of WHO fibres per milligram of dust. The dustiness tests deliver the same quantity directly, as counted fibres per milligram of raised dust.

QuarryMean fibre weightGeoSphere's approach: WHO fibres per mg of dustDustiness tests: WHO fibres per mg of dust
Rumpersdorf1.07 × 10⁻⁷ mgabout 280,000110,000 to 346,000
Badersdorf3.10 × 10⁻⁷ mgabout 97,00041,000 to 79,000
Pilgersdorf3.45 × 10⁻⁷ mgabout 87,00025,000 to 59,000
Bernstein5.57 × 10⁻⁷ mgabout 54,00027,000 to 60,000

GeoSphere's approach (3% divided by the mean fibre weight, our own calculation) is 1.2 to 2 times the respective mean of the six runs. At Rumpersdorf and Bernstein it lies within the range of the single runs, at Badersdorf and Pilgersdorf above every single run. The runs rest on 8 to 30 counted WHO fibres each. Sources: mean fibre weight from GeoSphere 2026a, Table 2-5, and Kochberger and WRUSS 2026a to 2026d, in each case Table 7 (p. 16); dustiness tests in each case Figures 2 and 3 (pp. 18 and 19).

What the TRGS 517 procedures measure, and how their result differs from the mineral share, is set out in the methodological context on the standards page.

2. Linearity and the expectation range of the overall version

On page 24 the overall version names an expectation range that extends beyond the 3% used:

"Measurements in the quarries show on average 30 to 50 mass percent asbestos […]. This corresponds to an expected content of 2% to 5% WHO fibres in the dust."

At the same place, the single-quarry versions (section 2.7, p. 20) and the Pilgersdorf recalculation (section 2.8, p. 22) say instead: "For the investigations, the mass fraction of WHO fibres in the inhalable dust […] is used as the basis, not the mass fraction of total asbestos in the rock."

At 3%, the value used lies in the lower part of the range of 2 to 5% that the overall version gives. The June reports cover the range only in part: the means of the laboratory fractions, at 0.86 to 1.71%, lie below it, while three of the four maxima and two of the four settled dusts lie within it. They also reach the starting quantity of the expectation only in places: the total asbestos content, averaged over the fractions below and above 0.1 mm, is 5.51% (Pilgersdorf), 9.52% (Badersdorf), 16.05% (Rumpersdorf) and 22.88% (Bernstein); within the range of 30 to 50% lie the laboratory fraction from Bernstein at 41.42% (in each case Table 6) and the settled dust from Rumpersdorf at 48.5% (Table 4). The choice of the value would matter little if the model reacted weakly to this parameter. But it is linear: the asbestos mass content is applied as a scalar to the PM10 results only after the actual dispersion calculation (section 2.7: "the PM10 results are first scaled to 3%", after which the asbestos mass is converted into a fibre count via the mean fibre weight). Annual mean and 95th percentile therefore scale directly in proportion to the chosen percentage.

A worked example: at the Rumpersdorf hunting lodge RD-01, the modelled annual mean is 730 WHO fibres/m³ and the 95th percentile is 4,353. Using the upper end of the overall version's expectation range, 5% instead of 3% (factor 5/3), the annual mean rises to about 1,220 and the 95th percentile to about 7,255 WHO fibres/m³. Even the annual mean then exceeds the Taskforce guidance value of 1,000 WHO fibres/m³, which is still undershot in the model at 3%. Conversely, using the Rumpersdorf mean of 1.71%, the annual mean falls to about 420 and the 95th percentile to about 2,480 WHO fibres/m³. None of the three versions examines the effect of such a variation of the input parameters. A sensitivity analysis is missing.

3. What the model structurally cannot see

GRAMM/GRAL calculates the instantaneous air concentration from the ongoing, direct quarry emissions. It does not represent three things:

  • Fibres that settle on surfaces: roads, gardens, roofs, playgrounds.
  • Material that accumulates over the entire operating life of the quarries.
  • Resuspension of this deposited material by wind, traffic or human activity.

This secondary reservoir is an independent exposure path that the model does not capture methodologically. This is not a statement about whether the modelled primary values are too high or too low, but about a gap in the model's scope. Conversely, one of the model assumptions is conservative in itself: because no deposition is calculated, the fibres behave like a gas that does not settle out, which tends to overstate rather than understate the direct plume. That is precisely why one cannot say blanketly that "all assumptions act in the same direction". The defensible, narrower statement is: on the axis of asbestos content the 3-percent input value is not a secure ceiling, and the secondary path is missing entirely.

4. A representative weather year

The calculation uses the weather of 2023. GeoSphere ranked the years 2021 to 2025 at several measuring stations by their wind distribution. 2023 came "most often in the first two places" (GeoSphere 2026d, section 4.1, p. 24). At the Bernstein station, 2023 came in at rank 4 of 5 (Table 4-1). Representative therefore means typical, not unfavourable. GeoSphere did not calculate a less favourable year. By its own account, GeoSphere calculates wind erosion "in the sense of a conservative estimate": it includes it for all winds above 3 m/s, although the mean wind speed at the Bernstein quarry in 2023 was below 2 m/s (GeoSphere 2026c, p. 17).

Why the guidance value is not a safety margin

The value of 1,000 WHO fibres/m³, often treated in the debate as a threshold, is a guidance value that the Burgenland Taskforce chose itself (the Land calls it a reference value), not a statutory limit value. According to the Land in February 2026, there was no such limit value for outdoor air outside a workplace in connection with asbestos-bearing rock; according to the same statement, the Taskforce set the value "deliberately very low", and it corresponds to the value of the Umweltbundesamt (environment agency) for harmlessness to third parties after asbestos remediation (Land Burgenland 2026). For asbestos, an IARC group 1 substance (carcinogenic to humans; IARC 2012), however, the WHO states: "No safe level can be proposed for asbestos because a threshold is not known to exist" (WHO 2000). A value "below the guidance value" therefore does not mean "free of risk"; it means only that the assessment threshold chosen by the Taskforce has not been reached. This is the yardstick against which the modelled values are to be read: several receptor points already lie, in the model with the 3-percent approach, at several hundred WHO fibres/m³ as an annual mean and above a thousand as a 95th percentile, and on the asbestos-content axis the 3-percent input value is not a secure ceiling.

Conclusion

The GeoSphere dispersion calculation is a usable first tool. Its values are not a secure ceiling of the real exposure: the secondary exposure path via deposited and resuspended material lies outside the model, and the 3-percent input value is a single maximum from a dust fraction produced in the laboratory. On the axis of asbestos content, the direction remains open. Against the 3% as a ceiling stand the settled dust from Rumpersdorf at 3.4%, the unmeasured transfer to PM10 and the possible formation of new fibres under repeated stress. Pointing to a lower mean content are the means of the laboratory fractions of 0.86 to 1.71%, three of the four settled dusts and all dustiness tests. Because the model scales all PM10 results with a single factor, the real annual mean depends on the mean content of the emitted dust. Measurements of the asbestos content in PM10 and a sensitivity analysis across the range of the content and of the fibre weights would narrow this uncertainty. Until then: the figures are robust as an order of magnitude, but not as a point estimate with a safety reserve on top.

Sources

We hold the documents marked "not published"; we make the quoted passages available on request.

  • GeoSphere Austria (2026a): "Die Ausbreitung von Asbest, ausgehend von den Steinbrüchen in Pilgersdorf, Bernstein, Rumpersdorf und Badersdorf" [The dispersion of asbestos from the quarries in Pilgersdorf, Bernstein, Rumpersdorf and Badersdorf], file number 2026/UM/000160, version 1.1, 29 April 2026, 131 pages. Pp. 11 and 13, Table 2-5 (p. 25), section 2.7 (pp. 24 and 25), chapter 5 (p. 53), Tables 5-1 to 5-4 (pp. 64, 67, 70, 73) and 6-1 to 6-4, section 7.2, summary p. 80. Not published.
  • GeoSphere Austria (2026b): "Die Ausbreitung von Asbest, ausgehend vom Steinbruch Pilgersdorf" [The dispersion of asbestos from the Pilgersdorf quarry], file number 2026/UM/000160, as of 2 June 2026, 62 pages. Section 2.8 (pp. 22 and 23), section 5.2 (p. 35) and Table 5-1 (p. 37), section 7.1 (pp. 39 and 40). Not published.
  • GeoSphere Austria (2026c): "Die Ausbreitung von Asbest, ausgehend vom Steinbruch in Bernstein" [The dispersion of asbestos from the quarry in Bernstein], file number 2026/UM/000160, version 1.1, 29 April 2026, 61 pages. Section 2.3 (p. 7), section 2.6.4 (p. 17), section 2.7 (p. 20). Not published.
  • GeoSphere Austria (2026d): "Die Ausbreitung von Asbest, ausgehend vom Steinbruch Rumpersdorf" [The dispersion of asbestos from the Rumpersdorf quarry], file number 2026/UM/000160, version 1.1, 29 April 2026, 65 pages. Section 2.7 (p. 20), section 4.1 and Table 4-1 (p. 24). Not published.
  • Kochberger, M.; ESW Consulting WRUSS Ziviltechnikergesellschaft mbH (2026a): Befund und Gutachten, Steinbruch Rumpersdorf [Findings and expert opinion, Rumpersdorf quarry]. Report k/kuv260864 to the Bezirkshauptmannschaft Oberwart, Vienna, 8 June 2026, main part 35 pages. Pp. 6, 8 and 14, Table 4 (p. 13), Table 6 (p. 15), Table 7 (p. 16), p. 17, Figures 2 and 3 (pp. 18 and 19), summary of findings (pp. 20 and 21), pp. 24 and 26, Table 8 (p. 25), p. 31. Not published.
  • Kochberger, M.; ESW Consulting WRUSS Ziviltechnikergesellschaft mbH (2026b): Befund und Gutachten, Steinbruch Badersdorf. Report k/kuv260854 to the Bezirkshauptmannschaft Oberwart, Vienna, 8 June 2026, main part 36 pages. Table 4 (p. 13), Table 6 (p. 15), Table 7 (p. 16), Figures 2 and 3 (pp. 18 and 19). Not published.
  • Kochberger, M.; ESW Consulting WRUSS Ziviltechnikergesellschaft mbH (2026c): Befund und Gutachten, Steinbruch Bernstein. Report k/kuv260860 to the Bezirkshauptmannschaft Oberwart, Vienna, 8 June 2026, main part 35 pages. Table 4 (p. 13), Table 6 (p. 15), Table 7 (p. 16), Figures 2 and 3 (pp. 18 and 19). Not published.
  • Kochberger, M.; ESW Consulting WRUSS Ziviltechnikergesellschaft mbH (2026d): Befund und Gutachten, Steinbruch Pilgersdorf. Report k/kuv261684 to the Bezirkshauptmannschaft Oberpullendorf, Vienna, 8 June 2026, main part 35 pages. Table 4 (p. 13), Table 6 (p. 15), Table 7 (p. 16), Figures 2 and 3 (pp. 18 and 19). Not published.
  • GRAL (2026): GRAL Dispersion Model, source-code repositories (README of the GRAL repository; description of the GUI repository). github.com/GralDispersionModel, accessed 17 October 2026.
  • IARC (2012): Asbestos (Chrysotile, Amosite, Crocidolite, Tremolite, Actinolite, and Anthophyllite). IARC Monographs on the Evaluation of Carcinogenic Risks to Humans 100C:219-309. publications.iarc.who.int
  • Land Burgenland (2026): Taskforce "Vorsorgeabklärung Luftqualität" präsentiert Ergebnisse der ersten Messreihe [Taskforce presents results of the first measurement series]. Landesmedienservice, 19 February 2026. burgenland.at
  • Öttl, D. (2015a): A multiscale modelling methodology applicable for regulatory purposes taking into account effects of complex terrain and buildings on pollutant dispersion: a case study for an inner Alpine basin. Environmental Science and Pollution Research 22: 17860-17875. doi:10.1007/s11356-015-4966-9
  • Öttl, D. (2015b): Quality assurance of the prognostic, microscale wind-field model GRAL 14.8 using wind-tunnel data provided by the German VDI guideline 3783-9. Journal of Wind Engineering and Industrial Aerodynamics 142: 104-110. doi:10.1016/j.jweia.2015.03.014
  • TRGS 517: Tätigkeiten mit potenziell asbesthaltigen mineralischen Rohstoffen und daraus hergestellten Gemischen und Erzeugnissen [Activities involving potentially asbestos-containing mineral raw materials and the mixtures and products made from them]. Edition February 2013, GMBl 2013 pp. 382-396 of 9 April 2013, amended GMBl 2015 pp. 137-138 of 2 March 2015; Annex 2, procedures 1 to 3. Federal Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (BAuA). copy on ungiftig.at (PDF), baua.de
  • WHO (2000): Air Quality Guidelines for Europe, Second Edition. WHO Regional Publications, European Series 91, chapter 6.2 Asbestos, pp. 128-135. WHO Regional Office for Europe, Copenhagen. iris.who.int

Questions on the topic? → Contact

Let's talk about your building

Write to us or call.

Send a message

We'll get back to you within one business day.

Free

Direct line

The fastest way to reach us is usually in writing, by email. Prefer to talk your project through on the phone? Call us and we'll work out together which service fits and plan the next steps.

Free

Price calculator

Combine inspection, samples and travel and see the approximate cost immediately.

Estimate costs